As a Maritimer I wished to share my high picks for seafood at PEI eating places, together with one of the best eating places in Charlottetown and the place to seek out one of the best lobster in PEI. Don’t neglect the oysters for the legendary PEI beef.
Enjoyable truth: Do you know that Nova Scotia and PEI as soon as shared an space code as a result of we have been each so small?
Whereas we’ve gotten larger we nonetheless share 902 but in addition have our personal. However the two Canadian provinces are nonetheless fairly linked.
The truth is, many Nova Scotians make at the least one journey to PEI over the summer season.
We love the pink sand seashores, golf programs and tradition that’s totally different sufficient from our personal that it appears like a vacation.
I’ve so many nice reminiscences rising up, then later judging the chowder competitors for the PEI Worldwide Shellfish Competition.
I cherished returning this summer season a lot that I’ve already satisfied my sister that we have to take her youngsters to PEI for the primary time subsequent summer season.
As a Maritimer I grew up with quite simple Nova Scotian meals, however seafood was all the time a continuing.
My grandmother made Nova Scotia chowder most Fridays. I bear in mind after we wanted to be careful for bones when consuming fish, and lobster was and nonetheless is my favorite meals.
However identical to not all meals in Italy is superb, not all seafood within the Maritimes is scrumptious.
So this put up is for my pals, who need the Atlantic Canada expertise.
As a result of I’m afraid they’ll get caught going to a vacationer joint that sells the captain’s frozen fish sticks – though that was additionally certainly one of my favorite suppers rising up so I suppose it’s kind of genuine.
There are some good spots to eat seafood in Charlottetown. However one of the best spots are outdoors town and across the island.
Don’t be intimidated by driving, Prince Edward Island is small however stunning.
Driving out to those spots provides you a terrific understanding of simply how numerous the island is.
Greatest PEI Eating places
Meals is subjective and so I can solely share what I believe are one of the best eating places in PEI
If I ate at a restaurant and wouldn’t return, or couldn’t suggest it to a buddy, I didn’t embody it on this listing.
There are a pair spots that always make all of the lists however cooks have modified and are actually simply dwelling off their status.
I discovered a few of the Charlottetown eating places actually had mediocre lobster rolls and there may be one well-known joint that I visited and left off the listing.
I’m fairly positive they used beforehand frozen lobster.
However why hassle spending the time to let you know the place to not go, as a substitute let’s concentrate on celebrating all of the scrumptious PEI eating places to go to.
Greatest Lobster Rolls on PEI
The Lobster Barn Pub and Eatery
Situated in picturesque Victoria by the Sea, you possibly can’t miss this restaurant on the wharf.
Though it might seem to scream vacationer lure, that is the place many locals go and so the costs are fairly cheap because it’s open yr spherical and so it should survive with native help.
It was began by two sisters in 2009 and on the menu it says:
Eat no matter you need. And if somebody tries to lecture you, eat them too!
The lobster roll ($17) is a really beneficiant portion of recent lobster on a buttered bun, served with a selection of fries, potato salad, onion rings, home salad or caesar salad.
Curiously additionally they put a little bit of sugar of their mayo so it’s a bit candy. I’ve by no means had it like that however I actually loved it.
The menu is huge with veggie choices and notably appetizer mussels and a beer ($10), chilled lobster dinner ($26), scallops ($19), bar clam burger ($16) and Wharf Platter with scallops, haddock and lobster ($26).
However get there early, I finished in at 11:15am and was in a position to sit at a desk overlooking the water however in a span of ten minutes the joint was packed.
The Lobster Barn
19 Fundamental St, Victoria, PE C0A 2G0
Lin’s Take Out
Okay technically not a lobster roll per se, however Lin’s is thought for the lobster burger.
So it’s a spherical bun vs a roll, and it comes with tomato – which some individuals assume may be very controversial however I loved it.
Situated simply outdoors Greenwich Nationwide Park it’s a small spot with picnic tables serving ice cream, burgers and varied fried seafood.
Lin’s Take Out
959 Greenwich Rd
Saint Peters Bay, PE C0A 2A0
The Lobster Shack on Souris Seashore
Owned by legendary fisherman Johnny Flynn, that is THE place for a lobster roll in addition to his Coleville Oysters and recent or cooked lobster.
Not surprisingly they gained the 2017 PEI Lobster Roll Problem.
Chef Jason Mullin, the Sous Chef at Inn at Bay Fortune, advised me The Lobster Shack had among the finest no frills lobster rolls in PEI.
And he was proper!
I’m a purist, I wish to style lobster on my rolls, don’t mess up the flavour by throwing a bunch of issues on high of it!
This was a lightweight base of mayo with a buttered sizzling canine bun, served with potato chips and some pickles for $12.95.
Easy is normally one of the best, and this is likely one of the cheaper rolls on the island, however don’t let that idiot you.
With a view you possibly can’t beat, they overlook the seashore. In the event you can solely drive to 1 location in PEI to eat this may be the one.
Open seasonally June 15 – September 15.
The Lobster Shack
8 Fundamental Road, Souris
Greatest Fish and Chips on PEI
Richard’s Recent Seafood
PEI eating places all the time have fish and chips on the menu however Richard’s is called one of the best.
Though the declare to dame is one of the best fish and chips, the whole lot right here is so beloved by locals it’s merely referred to as Richards for nearly 40 years.
It’s additionally a fish mart in case you’d like to purchase seafood to go and costs are very fairly primarily based on market costs.
It opens in June and sadly they closed for the season on September eighth, 5 days earlier than I arrived.
It’s greatest to keep watch over their Fb web page for updates.
9 Wharf Rd, York, PE C0A 1P0
The place to Eat Oysters in PEI
Prince Edward Island has a few of the greatest oysters on the planet.
On the Worldwide Shellfish Competition I attempted 21 totally different sorts and it’s not possible to say which one is one of the best as they’re all so totally different.
James Sturdy from Raspberry Level suggests in search of oysters with a deep shell as a substitute of a shallow one.
And whereas many PEI eating places provide a cheerful hour buck a shuck he isn’t a fan.
Whereas it helps native bars and eating places get individuals in early, it encourages the manufacturing of low cost oysters that may develop shortly as a substitute of high quality.
You get what you pay for with oysters.
My greatest recommendation is to attempt many and select what you want.
Blue Mussel Cafe
This PEI cafe is a value a drive simply to see North Rustico, which is so fairly – but in addition very chilly off season so deliver a sweater.
I didn’t order the chowder right here after judging 21 totally different sorts on the Worldwide Shellfish Competition.
As a substitute, I opted for the seafood bubbly bake ($21), which was like a thickened chowder with cheese.
A lot for going mild!
Blue Mussel Cafe did enter the competitors and after discovering their entry and whereas they didn’t win they have been a robust contender.
This is likely one of the hottest PEI eating places for vacationers, however don’t let the come from aways deter you from consuming right here.
Open from Might to October with the primary seating at 11:30 and ultimate at 9pm, with a fast closure from 4-5pm.
Go early at 4:30pm and put your identify on the dinner listing (no reservations) as they’ll provide you with a buzzer to let you realize when your desk shall be prepared.
There’s loads of instagram pleasant spots to stroll round whereas ready for dinner.
Blue Mussel Cafe
312 Harbourview Dr, North Rustico Harbour
I completely cherished staying in in Georgetown and the Factors East Coastal Drive was a spotlight.
I stayed at this unimaginable cottage from Airbnb simply throughout the Wheelhouse and it was improbable.
In earlier years I’ve spent a lot of my time in Charlottetown however now I’d suggest simply staying at day or two max.
I extremely suggest grabbing a drink and oysters to catch the sundown right here. The golden hues hitting the water are the whole lot you need in a vacation.
Gallants Seafood Market
Gallant’s is a seafood provider on the island. You will discover them on the Charlottetown Farmer’s market or on the seafood market in New London.
It’s a small store the place you possibly can decide up seafood to go or order from a really small menu and eat at certainly one of two tables out entrance.
EASY RECIPE: Snow Crab Truffles
I used this photograph of the Belle River rock crab truffles to emphasise that it is best to go for PEI oysters AND get one of the best crab truffles I’ve ever had.
I attempted to get the recipe from them…however sadly it’s a secret.
And in case you haven’t had lobster they are going to cook dinner and crack it for you for under $2 further per pound, which can be a steal.
They’ll even provide you with melted butter though personally I skip the butter because it interferes with the scrumptious style of lobster.
Gallant’s Seafood Market
10056 Rout 6, Stanley Bridge
(902) 886 2716
Carr’s Oyster Home
Simply across the nook from Gallants in New London, Carr’s has a terrific view of New London Bay.
Follow the uncooked oysters on the half shell vary from $2.50 – $6 per oyster.
The $6 oyster is called the George Carr particular they usually’ll warn you earlier than ordering because it’s fairly massive.
Carr’s Oyster Barr
32 Campbellton Street, Stanley Bridge
Previous Dublin Pub
If you wish to attempt buck a shuck oysters, the Previous Dublin Pub in Charlottetown is likely one of the hottest locations to go.
It’s upstairs from the Claddaugh Oyster home, and serve buck a shuck from 4-6pm day by day.
They provide small selection oysters for $1 every with the acquisition of an alcoholic beverage.
Previous Dublin Pub
131 Sydney St, Charlottetown
Greatest Tremendous Eating Restaurant in PEI
Inn at Bay Fortune has all the time been thought-about among the finest PEI eating places.
The Fireworks expertise (pre-2020) started with a reception wandering the grounds, consuming Coleville Bay Oysters and different island delicacies and transfer to a household model dinner of native meals cooked over a hearth.
And in 2020 as area and outside eating was mandatory there was a big picnic on the grounds that was a as soon as in a lifetime expertise.
So who is aware of what 2021 will deliver?
Chef Michael Smith is aware of how you can entertain friends so I’ve little doubt it is going to be something lower than unimaginable.
Inn at Bay Fortune
758 Route 310, Souris
Greatest Charlottetown Eating places
This PEI espresso store has a number of places round Charlottetown. Sure the small city of Charlottetown has 4 places.
I didn’t count on a lot for breakfast from the Brass Store location however they’ve a pleasant outside eating area.
And the breakfast sandwich was improbable with a selfmade bun, mustard pickles and bacon.
The French toast was additionally a terrific choice for people who choose a candy breakfast in Charlottetown.
Though I don’t take into account myself somebody who likes breakfast I’d completely return once more.
Stir it Up Vegan Kitchen
Situated in Founders Corridor meals corridor and market, this can be among the finest eating places in Charlottetown. Definitely it was essentially the most stunning.
Chef Ilona Daniel all the time has improbable suggestions for eating places in Prince Edward Island. So when she advised me to attempt the Mooless Mac at Stir it Up I knew I needed to go.
This vegan restaurant is mockingly positioned subsequent to a burger be a part of within the meals corridor and appeared to be busier once I was there.
Maybe everybody had heard that their vegan tackle a Huge Mac was unimaginable and one of the best knock off of the long-lasting burger.
Founders Corridor is a good spot to seize a chunk, it’s also licensed so you possibly can eat inside or take a neighborhood craft beer to the surface patio.
One of many extra established Charlottetown eating places, there’s a brand new location in Peake’s Wharf, which is a good spot to wander.
I used to be interested in this roll as there may be an choice to purchase a chilly roll (commonest), sizzling roll (with butter, lemon, garlic) or a half and half.
It’s on the small aspect, though lobster rolls ($21) are made with 4 oz. of PEI lobster, which they proclaim “greater than you’d get from a full 1 lb. lobster dinner!”
I don’t know any Maritimer who would eat a 1lb lobster, it’s so small.
In the event you solely have time to eat in Charlottetown this can be a nice choice, tastier than others that get extra press within the metropolis.
It comes on a cut up roll together with native kettle chips. I’d keep on with the standard chilly roll.
Peake’s Wharf, 5 Nice George St, Charlottetown, PE C1A 4J6
Sugar Cranium Cantina
One of many extra trendy eating places in Charlottetown, in spite of everything not the whole lot has to have a nautical theme.
This isn’t a lobster roll, however appropriately a lobster taco from a Mexican cantina impressed restaurant. Sugar Cranium Cantina is the sister restaurant to Hopyards and each deliver a youthful, hip really feel to Charlottetown which I like.
I wasn’t positive what I’d take into consideration this innovation. I’m an old style lobster purist – I prefer it chilly with out butter. On a boat from Panama to Colombia I had lobster in a tomato sauce and hated it.
However at Sugar Cranium it really works, they serve lobster with charred corn salsa, pink pepper mayo, iceburg lettuce and hickory sticks.
The portion is so beneficiant I believe it really works higher as a salad as most will fall out of the taco. It’s undoubtedly value popping in for one.
Sugar Cranium Cantina
83 Water Road, Charlottetown
Greatest Lobster in PEI That I Missed
Seasonal meals truck Terry’s Berries has grow to be highly regarded for its heat Salt Daddy Lobster Soften ($16.31).
It’s served on a hearty baguette with garlic and chives so it’s not conventional and undoubtedly a “soften”.
I made the error of coming to the truck the Sunday after the Shellfish Competition. I believe Terry could have had an excessive amount of enjoyable so he wasn’t open however he did keep open till September twentieth.
Be sure you test the Fb web page for hours.
20 Nice George St, Charlottetown
Lobster Supper in PEI: The place Do Locals Eat?
In the event you’re questioning the place to seek out one of the best lobster in PEI it’s all the time at somebody’s residence.
Maritimers completely eat seafood chowder at eating places and lobster rolls for a deal with, however we don’t eat lobster in eating places.
It’s too costly. Certain, we *would possibly* take our higher Canadian pals out someplace that we go to annually with vacationers.
Nevertheless it’s more likely that we’ll cook dinner it at residence and serve it to them in our yard.
That mentioned, there’s nothing incorrect with consuming a lobster dinner with fellow vacationers.
In the event you’re on the island for the Worldwide Shellfish Competition there’s prone to be a lobster supper in PEI and locals are there.
If you wish to go to a proper lobster supper (sure we name it supper not dinner) in PEI, the Fisherman’s Wharf, New Glasgow is well-known and has been round since 1958.
You may additionally search for a neighborhood fundraiser lobster supper for locals.
Or in case you’d like lobster with out the fuss purchase it cooked from Gallants, Richards or the Lobster Shack talked about above.
Greatest Time to Go to Prince Edward Island
Whereas the summer season has the warmest climate it additionally has essentially the most crowds. I believe one of the best time to go to Prince Edward Island is the start of September.
The climate continues to be heat and the crowds are gone so you may get actually reasonably priced lodging.
Plus there’s Shellfish Fest! The one draw back is that the later you go in September, the extra you danger a few of the greatest seafood spots being closed.
In the event you’re frightened about swimming within the ocean let me guarantee you it’s ALWAYS freezing. So whether or not you go in July or September you’ll discover it chilly.
Greatest Locations to Keep in PEI
The Nice George is a boutique lodge in Prince Edward Island but it surely’s not one location.
You test in on the principal home and there’s complimentary breakfast together with espresso and tea all through the day.
Nevertheless, it’s a collection of historic buildings shut to one another. So you possibly can keep in a lodge room, suite, cottage or effectivity models.
They have been beneficiant sufficient to host me however took it a step additional.
Once I talked about my mom was coming with me to take a look at PEI eating places they booked us in a two bed room condominium.
I really like non-traditional lodging. It was improbable as there was a lot room AND a again patio with a barbecue.
In the event you’re touring with a bunch for just a few days this can be a nice solution to do it.
There’s a full kitchen and two bogs with plenty of area. I’d extremely suggest for a household or pals visiting.
Learn Critiques on TripAdvisor or Ebook on Expedia
The Nice George
58 Nice George St, Charlottetown, PE C1A 4K3
Different Lodging on PEI
Though I stayed at this unimaginable airbnb that I’d suggest to anybody, I believe it will have been enjoyable to sleep in a single day at these Shanty Stays.
Impressed by conventional fishing shanties at working harbours, these 12×12 rustic cabins are a cut price at $89/evening.
In the event you’re with a bunch and want an entire home or cottage:
Inform me what PEI eating places did I miss? Do you’ve got every other favorite eating places in Charlottetown that ought to be on this listing?
Wish to Know Extra About Prince Edward Island?
PEI Potato Mussel Chowder Recipe
The Final Small Abattoir on PEI
Making Gouda Cheese